1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Private Schools

Readers Respond: Should They Or Should They Not Be Allowed?

Responses: 8

By , About.com Guide

From the article: Using Cell Phones at School
Every student has a cellphone. Should its use be controlled? Should they be permitted on campus at all?

I Don't know

I don't really know if it is a good idea to ban cell phones. They are very valuable to kids. It would be so devastating if a teacher took away a $100 cell phone. I am a student and I always use my cell phone at home because a lot of things happen in my unlucky family. I would just feel safer at school if I were able to get a call or text from a relative to know that someone has passed away, been hurt, or has given birth.
—Guest Darlyn Hinajosa

Taking Fun Away

I think they should be allowed for fun stuff to do during school.
—Guest Guest JB

yes

They should be allowed so a parent can get a hold of them when they are at school. I guess they could just call the school but it would be a whole heck of a lot easier if they were just allowed in schools.
—Guest nickolas

our school's solution

I am a mother of four students. All go and get out of school due to club meetings, etc. at different times. I want them to have their phones in school. What our high school has done to cut down on class disruption is to take up the phone and require a parent pay $15 upon retrieval. This enlists the help of the parents who are majorly inconvenienced (I've paid twice in two years) to "persuade" their child not to use their phones. Yes, it's a pain for the teacher in the short-run, but the payoff for all involved is less cell usage, not to mention the "donations" to the general fund. I hate that it has to be this way, but it's better than the schools who are banning them altogether.
—Guest Carolyn

importen

We should be allowed to have cellphones because things do happen at home. For example if my mom had hurt herself I am one of her emergency contacts. Take my phone and I can't call my dad, my grandmom or any one I think can help my mom when I am in school.
—Guest shaquill ellison

Cell Phones

Why are we always fighting technology? If cell phones are the most effective inputting device, then let's figure out how to incorporate cell phones into our pedagogy. I can remember when we got our first car with a radio in it. At first, it was never used because my father thought listening to it would cause accidents. That opinion quickly changed after the first time he turn it on. We have bigger issues to face in North American education than cell phones in the classroom. How about tackling something far more fundamental to learning - say, the 12 month school year? (My apologies to those parents who need their sons and daughters to help with the farming.)
—Boomerlab

A Student's Viewpoint

Students should be allowed to bring cellphones to school for the following reasons: -Parents need to know where their kids are -a school lock down -school power is out -phone lines tide by other classmates -just to talk to someone if they having a bad day -if students turn cellphones off during class, then that will silence the distractions to other students. -Use the cellphone at lunch if necessary.
—Guest Brandon

Cellphones and Homesickness

As a mom, of a son who attends Georgetown Prep School as a boarding student, we painstakingly admit that we chose to take away our son.
—Guest KG

Discuss

Readers Respond
Did You Have To Take the ISEE?
Add Your Response

Explore Private Schools

About.com Special Features

Dinosaur Discoveries of the Decade

The top 10 fossil discoveries between 2000 and 2010. More >

How to Ace the GRE

Being well prepared is the first step; here are more essential suggestions. More >

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Private Schools
  4. For Parents
  5. Issues
  6. Cellphones - Having Cellphones at School>

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.